This capsule review originally appeared as part of our coverage of the 2013 Galway Film Fleadh
Brotherly Love – ★★★★½
The National have been on my radar since they released their 2005 album “Alligator”, it was their third full-length but was the jumpstart for a slow rise to the positions of indie-rock royalty that they now find themselves in. They’d been around for years before most people got in on the act and it’s been a long-hard slog showing that success didn’t come easy. Tom Berninger, brother of the lead-singer Matt figures it may not be that hard to be a successful touring band so is invited to come on tour with them and work as their backstage gopher. He figured it wouldn’t be that hard allowing him to party on the road a bit while making a rockumentary on the side.
What genetically sets The National apart is the fact that the band is made up of 2 sets of brothers either side of frontman Berninger. For years the band have fielded quirky questions on whether this is fun/advantageous/weird and so it feels kind of right to see the triangle complete with 3 sibling sets on-board.
Tom is a metal-head slacker who may be one of the most unintentionally funny men you’ve ever encountered in a music documentary. How much of it all is planned or being played for laughs is hard to know as Mistaken for Stranger is culled from 8 months of footage with the band, all edited together by Tom Berninger and his sister-in-law Carin Besser (trivia: a former fiction editor of The New Yorker). Either way the film will have you smiling for the best part of 80 minutes while also managing to pack a real emotional punch as the Berningers’ relationship evolves.
If you enjoy laughing at rock stars (who doesn’t) or exploring the myth of rock bands on tour then you will take something from the film. Needless to say it is rewarding, essential viewing for fans of the Ohio natives.
Released in Dublin’s Light House Cinema on 27th june 2014
Latest posts by Nigel (see all)
- Pod 80: Raising a glass to Tom Waits, Robert Redford, Sly Stallone and Tessa Thompson - December 13, 2018
- Pod #79 – Steve McQueen’s ‘Widows’, plus Bohemian Rhapsody, Mandy, Rosie & more - November 9, 2018
- Pod #78 – We watch ‘The Crying Game’, 1992’s most shocking film and legendary piece of Irish cinema - October 8, 2018
- Pod #77 – The ‘BlackKklansman’ and ‘Airplane!’ connection, American Animals, Searching, Lucky & more - August 29, 2018